Autism Matters
  • Home
  • Training
    • Talks
    • Exploring Autism
    • Exploring Being Autistic
  • Blog
  • About
    • Caroline's published articles
  • Services
    • Training and CPD
    • Talks
    • Consultations >
      • Consultation enquiry
      • Consultation confirmation/payment
      • Family consultation confirmation/payment
    • Exploring Being Autistic
    • Employers
  • Resources
  • Contact
  • Feedback

Who are the autism experts?

6/10/2014

0 Comments

 
I was talking to an occupational therapist about our respective work.  She asked me how I got into autism training and I explained that I became interested in autism and indeed passionate about spreading information about autism  due to discovering I was autistic five years ago. Her head jerked up, she looked straight at me and asked, well almost snapped, “How do you know you are autistic?  Who diagnosed you?”   I got the impression that if I was not able to answer these questions to her satisfaction, my autism would be considered invalid.  In that moment I was glad that I had an official diagnosis, so I could be believed and also bothered that it was needed for me to be believed.

The question that I asked myself is who should be believed about autism – people identifying as autistic or the disparate professionals empowered by the establishment to deliver diagnosis (which even their own peers or other groups of professionals often dispute)?

While it seems that there are people who are clearly autistic and others who are clearly not, there will always be some whose neurology is more difficult to call.  This does not negate the concept of autism, or the fact that autism can be an important part of a person’s identity. I would however argue that the definition of autism is cultural rather than scientific.
 
The fact that there is bi-sexuality and that some people are initially attracted to the members of one sex but then spend the lives with someone of the other sex does not invalidate the gay movement or the fact that homosexuality is a condition.  Homosexuality was removed from the DSM (the US psychiatric bible) as a result of pressure from the gay movement, society not the condition itself changed.   

In the brilliantly engaging book about maths for non-mathematicians “How not to be wrong - the Hidden Maths of Everyday Life” Jordan Ellenberg mentions how useful it was to think about how things should be defined rather than what they were.   If we look at autism from this point of view the issue is not what specific neurological differences underpin autism (nobody claims to have discovered this yet anyway) but who should define autism.  Should it be people who have studied psychology or medicine and looked at autism through that lens  or should it be people whose life experience resonates with the  current  view of autism and the autistic people they connect with? 

I find the insistence on the need for an “objective scientific” diagnosis when we have yet to identify biological markers somewhat bizarre (maybe it is my autistic literalism that says if you are saying it is more reliable and scientific, you need to evidence to support this).  It looks to me like a power grab by a group of people who have made careers in a field they see shifting away from their control.

Uta Frith, for example, previously suggested that Asperger’s Syndrome might better be regarded, not as “a very mild form of deficit” but as “compensatory learning in the presence of a severe deficit”.  This statement appears to acknowledge that it is not possible to calibrate the level of difference or difficulty experienced by an individual from the outside.  However last year she claimed in a radio debate  “Rethinking what is normal”  that many people are inappropriately claiming they “have autism” when actually they ‘just’ have social difficulties.  I fail to see how Uta Frith can legitiately claim for herself and other similar professionals the ability to know what is inside another person.  In the October 2014 issue of the Psychologist she says  “If the voices of people with autism are also heard they will give an important counterbalance to researchers’ and professionals’ pronouncements”   but apparently only if the professionals get to validate which voices count as truly autistic.

My belief is that if we start to think of autism as a way of describing a natural part of the human neuro-diverse constellation rather than a definition of a medical  disorder that needs to be diagnosed by a professional, we’ll be moving forwards.
0 Comments

    Categories

    All
    Communication
    Diagnosis
    Disability
    Empathy
    Employment
    Language
    Masking
    Neurodiversity
    Non Verbal Communication
    Non-verbal Communication
    Sensory Issues
    Socialising
    Stigma
    Support
    Theory Of Mind
    Therapy
    Women

    Get Updates

    Blog posts in alphabetical order of titles


    Autism -  ordinary or extraordinary?
    
    
    Autistic people can be social


    Autistic women, do we even exist?

    Autism and social skills

    Difference, disability or Gucci diagnosis?

    Context or content?

    Does language affect our attitudes to autism?

    Everybody has an autism spectrum condition

    Is everyone a bit autistic?

    Mild autism?

    Sensory Issues

    The A Word, drama with explicit autism

    To mask, or not to mask, that is the question.

    The S word (stigma)

    What do we do with effective support?

    What you want always wanted to know about autism but were afraid to ask

    Who are the autism experts?

    Who decides if I'm autistic?

    Who or what is TOM and what does he or it have to do with autism?

    Why quicker diagnosis of autism is useful now, but hopefully won’t be needed in future


    Other blogs

    Autism age. Incisive blog by Cos Michael who specailises in autism and aging.

    RSS Feed

    Archives

    December 2020
    August 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    September 2018
    August 2018
    April 2018
    May 2017
    April 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    November 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    September 2015
    May 2015
    January 2015
    October 2014
    July 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    January 2014
    October 2013
    September 2013
    July 2013

get updates
Picture